Scoring Rubrics
Each audition area is evaluated by trained adjudicators using the rubrics below. Review the criteria and point values to understand how performances are scored.
Adjudicator Review
Trained adjudicators independently evaluate each student using the criteria below.
Points Totaled
Each criterion is scored up to its maximum points. All scores are added together for a total.
Threshold Met
Total scores are compared against each area's threshold to determine placement eligibility.
Choose a school level to see the rubrics used for those grades.
Creative Writing Rubric (Elementary)
Max Score
50
Threshold
40
Creativity and Originality
A. The writer manifests exceptional imaginative skills, original
B. Stream of significant ideas unusual for development level (Fluency)
C. Shifts categories often and with ease, flexible and creative (Flexibility)
D. Vivid imagery, complex details, unusual for developmental level (Elaboration)
E. Distinct approach, sophisticated ideas, completely original & unique (Originality)
Voice/Style
F. Creates a vivid, precise, and engaging writer’s voice and tone
Audience Awareness/Impact
G. The writer’s choices demonstrate an intimate awareness of their audience and the impact of their choices on the reader’s understanding and emotions
Clarity/ Coherence
H. The writer’s intention is clear and illuminating, and maintains focus
I. Organization is logically structured and enhances meaning
Word Choice
J. The writer masterfully employs literary techniques that extend throughout the piece, vividly capture the reader's imagination, and bring the story/ topic to life
Dance Rubric (Elementary)
Max Score
50
Threshold
40
CHOREOGRAPHY
A. Advanced comprehension of choreography
B. Able to connect movements in smooth and cohesive phrases and transitions
MUSICALITY
C. High degree of musicality in interpretation of sequence, demonstrating full range of dynamics, and moves whole body to underlying beat.
DANCE SKILLS & BODY AWARENESS
D. Demonstrates advanced skill to appropriate to dance genre(s) including alignment, turnout and control, flexibility and strength
E. Presence- consistently performs w/ fluidity, readiness, coherence, integration
F. Advanced level of body and spatial awareness by self and in group
ENERGY LEVEL & CONFIDENCE
G. Advanced ability to communicate ideas and feelings through expressiveness and intensity of movements.
GUIDED IMPROVISATION
H. Demonstrates advanced skill and understanding of the elements of dance through movement choices. Embraces spontaneity and originality
OVERALL EXECUTION
I. Clarity of movements, poise, confidence and expression
J. Outstanding artistry, full commitment to movement. Dances with focus, confidence, energy and artistry.
Drama Rubric (Elementary)
Max Score
50
Threshold
40
Physical Performance
A. Creatively uses variety of dynamic movements motivated from core and are natural including excellent use of space and varied dynamic levels.
B. Dynamic facial expression to create character
Vocal Performance
C. Exceptional use of voice including projection with variety of levels, engaging and dynamic vocal energy, outstanding articulation and vocal clarity and uses colorful/dynamic expression
Characterization
D. Fully developed character w/ complex, original choices that is exceptionally honest & believable demonstrating outstanding depth of understanding of given circumstances
Imagination, Creativity and Improvisation
E. Actively listens and engages in creative problem solving, exceptional skill in building on ideas of others.
F. Innovative and creative ideas with nuanced artistic choices
G. Embraces spontaneity and originality to create a highly effective and clever performance.
Energy & Focus
H. Energy is dynamic and engages whole body and performance; engaging and connected throughout demonstrating extraordinary focus.
Collaboration
I. Actively listens and engages in creative problem solving, exceptional skill in building on ideas of others and peer collaboration.
Overall Performance
J. Performance exhibits outstanding preparation, choices were creative and original, and demonstrates a high level of confidence.
Music Instrumental Rubric (Elementary)
Max Score
50
Threshold
40
A. Tone Quality
Tone is warm, resonant, controlled, clear, focused, consistent, vibrant, rich, full, and beautiful
Accuracy
B. Pitches/rhythms are performed accurately
Intonation
C. Intonation is within or above the appropriate developmental range. The student shifts cleanly if shifts are performed
Rhythm and Pulse
D. Gives notes and rests proper value and always maintains a steady pulse
Technique and Articulation
E. Student uses appropriate playing technique
F. Student uses appropriate articulation, including attacks and releases
Interpretation
G. Phrasing and dynamics are performed with nuance
H. The style and tempo are appropriate to the musical selection
I. The performance is expressive and sensitive to style
Level of Difficulty
J. Difficulty above or below grade level
Music Vocal Rubric (Elementary)
Max Score
50
Threshold
40
Tone Quality/ Technique
A. Tone is warm, resonant, focused, consistent, vibrant, and full
B. Consistent between head and chest voice
C. Breath management is effective and consistent
Intonation/ Rhythmic Accuracy
D. Printed pitches are performed accurately with great intonation
E. Notes and rests are held for the correct value with exceptional flow with steady tempo and musicality
Diction
F. Diction is clear and enhances breath flow.
Musicality
G. Phrasing emphasizes the contour of melodic line in context of the whole piece
H. Dynamic nuances are performed with finesse and artistic contrast
Performance
I. Student expresses themselves through the music selected demonstrating great enthusiasm and potential
J. Student has exceptional posture and poise in performance
Visual Arts Rubric (Elementary)
Max Score
50
Threshold
40
Composition
A. Artwork shows exceptional application of design
B. Organization of composition is complex and detailed
C. Demonstrates a highly refined awareness of detail, form, and proportion; captures nuanced aspects of observed subjects with originality and confidence (observational drawing).
Creativity and Originality
D. Artwork shows inventive adaptation and assimilation of complex themes
E. Personal style is evident and reflected through creative expression
F. Demonstrates creative risk-taking and strong visual storytelling (imaginative representation).
Skills & Craftsmanship
G. Exceptional technical skills are demonstrated when compared to same-age peers
H. Artwork demonstrates exceptionally unique and experimental use of media
Elements and Principles of Art
I. Elements are well-defined, deliberate, and used in complexity to achieve outstanding results
J. Student creates work that exhibits a high level of understanding and application of the Principles of Art
Creative Writing Rubric (Secondary)
Max Score
48
Threshold
39
Creativity and Originality
A. The writer manifests exceptional imaginative skills, original thinking, & risk taking
B. Creates worlds and characters with nuanced and meaningful depth and detail
C. Engages in startling and apt use of figurative language
D. Develops clear and striking imagery
E. Demonstrates complex risk taking through hybridity, metacognitive thinking & processing, and/or multimedia accompanying written work
Voice/Style
F. Creates a vivid, precise, and engaging writer’s voice and tone
G. Uses lyrically, denotatively, and connotatively rich diction
H. Varies complex syntax to affect pace, tone, and understanding
Elements of Genre, Form, Structure
I. Chosen genre, form, and/or structure enhances the mood, tone, and/or meaning
Audience Awareness & Impact
J. Choices demonstrate an intimate awareness of their audience and the impact of their choices on the reader’s understanding and emotions
Clarity/ Coherence
K. Writer’s intention is clear and illuminating; writer maintains clear focus; organization is logically structured and enhances meaning;
Mechanics
L. Sophisticated and innovative control of grammar, mechanics, spelling and usage, & sentence formation to enhance tone & style
Dance Rubric (Secondary)
Max Score
68
Threshold
55
SEQUENCING and RECALL
A. Advanced comprehension of choreography
B. Able to connect movements in smooth and cohesive phrases and transitions
TIME/RHYTHM
C. High degree of musicality in interpretation of sequence, demonstrating full range of dynamics
D. Moves whole body to underlying beat demonstrating advanced skill in feeling the beat
DANCE SKILLS & BODY AWARENESS
E. Demonstrates advanced skill in alignment, turnout and control, flexibility and strength, use of extension
F. Advanced skill appropriate to dance genre(s) demonstrated
G. Advanced coordination of skills to execute movements with precision and fluidity
H. Presence: consistently performs w/ fluidity, readiness, coherence, integration
I. Advanced level of body and spatial awareness by self and in group
ENERGY LEVEL & CONFIDENCE
J. Advanced ability to communicate ideas & feelings through expressivity, intensity of movement
K. Dances w/focus, confidence, energy, artistry
GUIDED IMPROVISATION
L. Demonstrates advanced skill and understanding of the elements of dance through movement choices
M. Communicates ideas and artistry through expression and movement choices
N, Embraces spontaneity and originality
OVERALL EXECUTION
O. Clarity of movements, poise, confidence and expression
P. Outstanding artistry, full commitment to movement
Q. Performance looks polished and effortless
Drama Rubric (Secondary)
Max Score
80
Threshold
64
Physical Performance
A. Creatively uses variety of dynamic movements motivated from core and natural
B. Creatively uses space, varied dynamic levels
C. Dynamic facial expression to create character
Vocal Performance
D. Exceptional projection of voice with variety of levels, engaging and dynamic vocal energy
E. Outstanding articulation and vocal clarity
F. Uses colorful/dynamic expression
Characterization
G. Fully developed character with complex, original choices that is exceptionally honest & believable
H. Shows outstanding depth of understanding of given circumstances
Improvisation
I. Exceptional use of Give and take/“yes and..” elevates peer collaboration
J. Cohesive, supported structure & presentation
K. Spontaneously creates a highly effective and clever improvisation
Imagination and Creativity
L. Innovative and creative ideas with nuanced artistic choices
M. Students adapts and responds with exceptional creativity throughout
Energy & Focus
N. Extraordinary focus, seamless performance
O. Energy is dynamic and engages whole body and performance. Engaging and connected throughout
Collaboration
P. Actively listens and engages in creative problem solving, exceptional skill in building on ideas of others
Q. Shares the space with skill and ease
Overall Performance
R. Shows high level of confidence
S. No difficulty or hesitation when encountering challenging material
T. Performance exhibits outstanding preparation, choices were creative and original
Drama Tech Rubric (Secondary)
Max Score
52
Threshold
42
Interpretation and Design
A. Exceptional and artistic organization in demonstration of given tasks
B. Design concepts are precise, clear, meaningful, and cohesive, employing symbolism, metaphor, and abstract thinking
C. Original artistic concept which enhances and embraces the vision
Aesthetics and Execution
D. Exceptional artistic vision, justification, precision, clarity of design
E. Exceptional detail and specificity which enhances the design
F. Dramatic elements seamlessly work to establish character, time, location, and enhances the mood of piece
Presentation
G. Demonstrates, highly artistic, comprehensive understanding of the play/story
H. Fully developed, creative justification synthesis of technical work. i.e. design elements & principles, collaboration, production concept, detail & descriptive elements
I. Presentation of the final product is innovative and compelling
J. Design & presentation is exceptionally organized & demonstrates deep understanding
Imagination and Creativity
K. Exceptional, precise ideas above grade level
L. Proposes innovative creative and/or unusual solutions above grade level
Collaboration and Focus
M. Excels above grade-level when encountering challenging material
Music Instrumental Rubric (Secondary)
Max Score
80
Threshold
64
Tone Quality
A. Tone is exceptionally warm, resonant, focused, consistent, vibrant, and full *Percussion: Exceptional tone with appropriate sick/mallet in the correct area of the instrument
Intonation/Rhythmic Accuracy
B. Printed pitches are performed accurately and intonation is masterful
C. Printed rhythms are performed accurately with precision including attacks & releases
D. Exceptional flow showing care with tempo nuances
Technique
E. Student interprets printed articulations stylistically and exceptionally musically
F. Technique is controlled, refined,& elevates the music
G. Student demonstrates mastery of instrument
H. Vibrato OR characteristic tone is controlled, refined, masterful, & elevates the music
Musicality
I. Phrasing emphasizes the contour of melodic line artistically throughout
J. Dynamic are performed with finesse and artistic contrast
K. Overall expression is artistic & nuanced
Performance
L. Musical selection is memorized and exceptionally well-prepared
M. Mistakes are nonexistent or expertly handled with fluency & control, keeping the flow of music
N. Posture and poise are exceptional and enhance the overall performance
O. Demonstrates exceptional enthusiasm and potential
On-Demand
Sight Reading
Level of Difficulty
Difficulty above or below grade level
Music Vocal Rubric (Secondary)
Max Score
70
Threshold
56
Tone Quality
A. Tone is warm, resonant, focused, consistent, vibrant, and full
Intonation/ Rhythmic Accuracy
B. Printed pitches are performed accurately and intonation is masterful
C. Printed rhythms are performed accurately and with precision
D. Exceptional flow with care to tempo nuances (with accompaniment recording and choice piece)
Technique
E. Consistency between head and chest voice demonstrates remarkable vocal facility
F. Breath management is effective & artistic
G. Diction is precise, enhances breath flow
H. Mastery of text enhances performance
Musicality
I. Phrasing emphasizes the contour of the melodic line artistically throughout
J. Dynamic are performed with finesse and artistic contrast
K. Overall expression is masterful, artistic, and nuanced
Performance
L. Musical selection is memorized and exceptionally well-prepared
M. Communicates masterful interpretation of story via facial expression and gesture.
N. Posture and poise are exceptional and enhance overall performance
O. Demonstrates exceptional enthusiasm and potential
On Demand Aural Skills
P. Tonal Patterns
Q. Rhythmic Patterns
Visual Arts Rubric (Secondary)
Max Score
40
Threshold
32
Composition
A. Artwork shows exceptional application of design
B. Organization of composition is complex and detailed
C. Demonstrates a highly refined awareness of detail, form, and proportion; captures nuanced aspects of observed subjects with originality and confidence.
Creativity and Originality
D. Artwork shows inventive adaptation and assimilation of complex themes
E. Personal style is evident and reflected through creative expression
F. Demonstrates creative risk-taking and strong visual storytelling
Skills & Craftsmanship
G. Exceptional technical skills are demonstrated when compared to same-age peers
H. Artwork demonstrates exceptionally unique and experimental use of media
Elements and Principles of Art
I. Elements are well-defined, deliberate, and used in complexity to achieve outstanding results
J. Student creates work that exhibits a high level of understanding and application of the Principles of Art
Creative Writing Rubric (Secondary)
Max Score
48
Threshold
39
Creativity and Originality
A. The writer manifests exceptional imaginative skills, original thinking, & risk taking
B. Creates worlds and characters with nuanced and meaningful depth and detail
C. Engages in startling and apt use of figurative language
D. Develops clear and striking imagery
E. Demonstrates complex risk taking through hybridity, metacognitive thinking & processing, and/or multimedia accompanying written work
Voice/Style
F. Creates a vivid, precise, and engaging writer’s voice and tone
G. Uses lyrically, denotatively, and connotatively rich diction
H. Varies complex syntax to affect pace, tone, and understanding
Elements of Genre, Form, Structure
I. Chosen genre, form, and/or structure enhances the mood, tone, and/or meaning
Audience Awareness & Impact
J. Choices demonstrate an intimate awareness of their audience and the impact of their choices on the reader’s understanding and emotions
Clarity/ Coherence
K. Writer’s intention is clear and illuminating; writer maintains clear focus; organization is logically structured and enhances meaning;
Mechanics
L. Sophisticated and innovative control of grammar, mechanics, spelling and usage, & sentence formation to enhance tone & style
Dance Rubric (Secondary)
Max Score
68
Threshold
55
SEQUENCING and RECALL
A. Advanced comprehension of choreography
B. Able to connect movements in smooth and cohesive phrases and transitions
TIME/RHYTHM
C. High degree of musicality in interpretation of sequence, demonstrating full range of dynamics
D. Moves whole body to underlying beat demonstrating advanced skill in feeling the beat
DANCE SKILLS & BODY AWARENESS
E. Demonstrates advanced skill in alignment, turnout and control, flexibility and strength, use of extension
F. Advanced skill appropriate to dance genre(s) demonstrated
G. Advanced coordination of skills to execute movements with precision and fluidity
H. Presence: consistently performs w/ fluidity, readiness, coherence, integration
I. Advanced level of body and spatial awareness by self and in group
ENERGY LEVEL & CONFIDENCE
J. Advanced ability to communicate ideas & feelings through expressivity, intensity of movement
K. Dances w/focus, confidence, energy, artistry
GUIDED IMPROVISATION
L. Demonstrates advanced skill and understanding of the elements of dance through movement choices
M. Communicates ideas and artistry through expression and movement choices
N, Embraces spontaneity and originality
OVERALL EXECUTION
O. Clarity of movements, poise, confidence and expression
P. Outstanding artistry, full commitment to movement
Q. Performance looks polished and effortless
Drama Rubric (Secondary)
Max Score
80
Threshold
64
Physical Performance
A. Creatively uses variety of dynamic movements motivated from core and natural
B. Creatively uses space, varied dynamic levels
C. Dynamic facial expression to create character
Vocal Performance
D. Exceptional projection of voice with variety of levels, engaging and dynamic vocal energy
E. Outstanding articulation and vocal clarity
F. Uses colorful/dynamic expression
Characterization
G. Fully developed character with complex, original choices that is exceptionally honest & believable
H. Shows outstanding depth of understanding of given circumstances
Improvisation
I. Exceptional use of Give and take/“yes and..” elevates peer collaboration
J. Cohesive, supported structure & presentation
K. Spontaneously creates a highly effective and clever improvisation
Imagination and Creativity
L. Innovative and creative ideas with nuanced artistic choices
M. Students adapts and responds with exceptional creativity throughout
Energy & Focus
N. Extraordinary focus, seamless performance
O. Energy is dynamic and engages whole body and performance. Engaging and connected throughout
Collaboration
P. Actively listens and engages in creative problem solving, exceptional skill in building on ideas of others
Q. Shares the space with skill and ease
Overall Performance
R. Shows high level of confidence
S. No difficulty or hesitation when encountering challenging material
T. Performance exhibits outstanding preparation, choices were creative and original
Drama Tech Rubric (Secondary)
Max Score
52
Threshold
42
Interpretation and Design
A. Exceptional and artistic organization in demonstration of given tasks
B. Design concepts are precise, clear, meaningful, and cohesive, employing symbolism, metaphor, and abstract thinking
C. Original artistic concept which enhances and embraces the vision
Aesthetics and Execution
D. Exceptional artistic vision, justification, precision, clarity of design
E. Exceptional detail and specificity which enhances the design
F. Dramatic elements seamlessly work to establish character, time, location, and enhances the mood of piece
Presentation
G. Demonstrates, highly artistic, comprehensive understanding of the play/story
H. Fully developed, creative justification synthesis of technical work. i.e. design elements & principles, collaboration, production concept, detail & descriptive elements
I. Presentation of the final product is innovative and compelling
J. Design & presentation is exceptionally organized & demonstrates deep understanding
Imagination and Creativity
K. Exceptional, precise ideas above grade level
L. Proposes innovative creative and/or unusual solutions above grade level
Collaboration and Focus
M. Excels above grade-level when encountering challenging material
Music Instrumental Rubric (Secondary)
Max Score
80
Threshold
64
Tone Quality
A. Tone is exceptionally warm, resonant, focused, consistent, vibrant, and full *Percussion: Exceptional tone with appropriate sick/mallet in the correct area of the instrument
Intonation/Rhythmic Accuracy
B. Printed pitches are performed accurately and intonation is masterful
C. Printed rhythms are performed accurately with precision including attacks & releases
D. Exceptional flow showing care with tempo nuances
Technique
E. Student interprets printed articulations stylistically and exceptionally musically
F. Technique is controlled, refined,& elevates the music
G. Student demonstrates mastery of instrument
H. Vibrato OR characteristic tone is controlled, refined, masterful, & elevates the music
Musicality
I. Phrasing emphasizes the contour of melodic line artistically throughout
J. Dynamic are performed with finesse and artistic contrast
K. Overall expression is artistic & nuanced
Performance
L. Musical selection is memorized and exceptionally well-prepared
M. Mistakes are nonexistent or expertly handled with fluency & control, keeping the flow of music
N. Posture and poise are exceptional and enhance the overall performance
O. Demonstrates exceptional enthusiasm and potential
On-Demand
Sight Reading
Level of Difficulty
Difficulty above or below grade level
Music Vocal Rubric (Secondary)
Max Score
70
Threshold
56
Tone Quality
A. Tone is warm, resonant, focused, consistent, vibrant, and full
Intonation/ Rhythmic Accuracy
B. Printed pitches are performed accurately and intonation is masterful
C. Printed rhythms are performed accurately and with precision
D. Exceptional flow with care to tempo nuances (with accompaniment recording and choice piece)
Technique
E. Consistency between head and chest voice demonstrates remarkable vocal facility
F. Breath management is effective & artistic
G. Diction is precise, enhances breath flow
H. Mastery of text enhances performance
Musicality
I. Phrasing emphasizes the contour of the melodic line artistically throughout
J. Dynamic are performed with finesse and artistic contrast
K. Overall expression is masterful, artistic, and nuanced
Performance
L. Musical selection is memorized and exceptionally well-prepared
M. Communicates masterful interpretation of story via facial expression and gesture.
N. Posture and poise are exceptional and enhance overall performance
O. Demonstrates exceptional enthusiasm and potential
On Demand Aural Skills
P. Tonal Patterns
Q. Rhythmic Patterns
Visual Arts Rubric (Secondary)
Max Score
40
Threshold
32
Composition
A. Artwork shows exceptional application of design
B. Organization of composition is complex and detailed
C. Demonstrates a highly refined awareness of detail, form, and proportion; captures nuanced aspects of observed subjects with originality and confidence.
Creativity and Originality
D. Artwork shows inventive adaptation and assimilation of complex themes
E. Personal style is evident and reflected through creative expression
F. Demonstrates creative risk-taking and strong visual storytelling
Skills & Craftsmanship
G. Exceptional technical skills are demonstrated when compared to same-age peers
H. Artwork demonstrates exceptionally unique and experimental use of media
Elements and Principles of Art
I. Elements are well-defined, deliberate, and used in complexity to achieve outstanding results
J. Student creates work that exhibits a high level of understanding and application of the Principles of Art